(732) 828-2261info@justcollect.com

Contact Us

Sell Sports Cards in NYC (Conveniently & Easily)

Turn your sports cards into cash.

Do you have a high-value sports card collection? Live in the New York metro area? Want to talk to an expert in person to help determine the value? Don’t want to pay the high fees and endure the long waits that come with using an auction house?  Want to make sure that your cherished collection goes to a good home and is appreciated for years to come?

We have the perfect solution for you.

You can now sell your sports cards, or your entire collection in person to Just Collect at Bleecker Trading, 96 Christopher St. NYC. Should you decide you’d like to sell, we’ll give you a free appraisal and a check right away on the spot.

Many auction houses take up to 20% commission (and a buyer's premium) and take months to complete the sale, but you can avoid all that with this unique opportunity. No waiting for months and paying premiums or commissions.

We are interested in all of the following:

  • Baseball cards
  • Football cards
  • Basketball cards
  • Hockey cards
  • Non-Sport cards (including Wrestling, Pokemon, Star Wars, Garbage Pail Kids, etc.)
  • Golf cards
  • Boxing cards
  • Sports memorabilia including autographs, jerseys, and game-used material
  • Unopened boxes and packs
  • Or any other cards of intrigue

Note: we are especially interested in vintage cards (produced from 1979 or before). We do buy select modern cards, but our interest is primarily centered around vintage. For more about the modern cards we are interested in buying, visit our modern sports card page.

Have you inherited a large collection? Been out of the hobby for a while?

Our knowledgeable representatives would be happy to take a look. Together, we’ll identify the cards and walk you through our valuation and offer. We also love buying large collections including sets, player collections, hand-me-down treasures, graded cards by PSA, SGC, BGS, and BVG, even cards that are taped to poster boards or glued into albums.

We have bought and sold over $50 million worth of sports cards, so we’ve seen a thing or two!

Learn more about the proprietor,

Leighton Sheldon.

A lifelong Yankees, Jets, and Celtics fan and collector, Leighton began his career as a Director of Acquisitions for a New York auction house. In 2006 he founded Just Collect and has since purchased over $50 million worth of sports cards and memorabilia from people across the U.S. and Canada.

Leighton prides himself on using a uniquely transparent buying and appraising process that utilizes actual, real-time market values to assess the overall value of a collection. 

Here are just three of the many collections we’ve purchased in the past few years, two of which came from NYC-area collectors:

Real Customer Reviews & Testimonials

“Leighton is an absolute pleasure to deal with and is the most honest person you will find in this category. My dad and I have already had many positive experiences.” --- Justin W.


“They say, “Three time’s a charm.” For me that saying holds true. I was finally able to get the fairest prices for my Goudey Baseball Cards from Just Collect after trying two other dealers.” --- Diane B.


“Very professional. No pressure. Very knowledgeable. Fair pricing. Overall a very good experience.” --- Charles N.


How it Works (Selling Process)

Fill out the form below, or simply bring your cards over to our location at 96 Christopher St, NYC. We are open Monday through Friday, 10AM to 6PM, and Saturdays and Sundays, 12PM to 5PM. One of our highly-trained representatives will review your collection with you, assess the condition of your cards, evaluate current market prices, help you determine the value, and, if possible, make you an offer for your collection. Should you choose to sell, you’ll get a check on the spot. That’s it. There’s no back and forth, no hassle, no smoke and mirrors, just an honest transaction.

Request an Appraisal & Schedule an Appointment:

Walk-ins are welcome, but emailing us ahead of time may expedite the process.


Do you have pictures of your cards on hand? You can get a free online sports card appraisal, and potentially an offer right away. Then simply walk in to Just Collect NYC to complete your transaction. We are here to make this process as easy as possible for you!

Have further questions? Email us at info@justcollect.com