(732) 828-2261info@justcollect.com

What makes us different?

Just Collect doesn’t just buy and sell cards, we share memories. We share the memories of your collection, memories of your relationships, memories of your stories about when the game was played for the love of the game.

View Videos

Selling Us Your Collection Is Easy

We make it easy for you to show us your collection with 4 simple methods that should work for anyone in North America!
Digital Scan
or Photography

The most common way we review collections is by having you send digital scans or photographs. A smartphone, any digital camera or flatbed digital scanner is sufficient for these purposes and we've written detailed instructions on how to do so.

Send them to us

For customers not within driving radius to meet at one of our locations, we ask that you ship us your cards. Return shipping is guaranteed and we are fully insured. We treat your cards as we would our own and handle them accordingly.

make an appointment to visit us

We have appraisal locations in NJ and NYC Metro area as well as a specialist in the Boca Roton FL area. To meet in one of these locations or our Somerset NJ headquarters appointment are required.

We’ll come to you

Sports card collections uncovered in a relative's attic or basement can be great finds but sometimes too delicate to ship. We often travel across the country (at our own expense) to evaluate more valuable collections or those too large to ship.

Easy FREE appraisal process

Simply follow these steps to find out what your collection is worth

Tell us
your story

Found under the couch? Handed down from your grandparents? Traded as a kid? Collected since childhood? Purchased on eBay? -- These stories add value!

Show us your collection

You can scan them, photograph them, ship them to us, visit us at our offices in New Jersey or we’ll come to visit you!

Get appraisal
& FREE offer

Our experts are ready to assist you NOW and help determine the current market value of your collection . . . for FREE!  We can also provide you with the best purchase offer in the hobby!  No one pays more!

Your collection has a story

We’ll help you tell it

View All Stories Tell Us Your Story

A Son's Gift - 1954 Topps Set with Banks and Aaron

We get phone calls all of the time from people telling us about cards that they've found or asking about collections that have been given from grandparents, parents and siblings. Rare is the call where someone has a collection that they've received from their children, but ...

Read Full Story

The 1956 Topps Twin Cities Collection

Just Collect acquires pack-fresh collection of 1956 Topps baseball cards, which includes Mickey Mantle, Hank Aaron, Roberto Clemente, Sandy Koufax, Jackie Robinson and Ted Williams!

View Video Archives

Offices In Somerset, Hoboken & the NYC Area

Helping You Sell Your Vintage Baseball and Sports Cards

Founded in 2006 by Leighton Sheldon, Just Collect, Inc. has been buying and selling sports cards and memorabilia for nearly a decade. Our main office in Somerset, NJ (5 minutes from the Rutgers-New Brunswick campus) allows our team to serve all of New Jersey, as well as New York City and Philadelphia. Depending on your collection’s size and value, we can travel to you or even pay to have your items shipped fully insured to our Somerset, NJ office.

Skilled Assistance With Your Sports Collectibles and Memorabilia

Just Collect is not just another baseball card store. We are the nation’s top buyer of vintage sports cards and memorabilia. We have bought and sold over $20 million worth of cards since our inception. We buy collections of all types every day! We buy vintage sports cards, non-sports cards, unopened packs, unopened boxes, cases, uncut sheets and many types of sports memorabilia and autographs!